Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Vaccination

Edward Jenner crashed on his future wife one day when his aircraft ran out of lift and forced him to land in her father's front yard. In 1788 flying was a novelty and hot air balloons were a miracle. The fearsome killer at the time however, was not flying wrecks but smallpox. One in three of those who contracted the disease died and many, many people lived their lives scarred and pitted by the pustules the disease formed on the skin. The fact that today one is hard put to come across an obvious survivor of smallpox, at least in our comfortable first world, is a tribute to Edward Jenner.The trouble with vaccines is that people have short memories. I attribute this generation's contempt for government regulation to a lack of institutional memory to remind people why government instituted regulations in the first place. We have social security disability and old age pensions today because people starved without them, literally, in the 1930s. US banks used to be tightly regulated because bank failure was commonplace and so the federal government created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation to protect the savings of working people. Vaccination programs were a public health response to sweeping waves of disease that killed and crippled.Dr Walter Reed, an army surgeon figured out yellow fever was mosquito-borne and his discoveries permitted the Panama Canal to reach completion.His work also paved the way for huge public health works to make modern cities safe. New Orleans, Rome, Key West, were all cities subject to outbreaks of deadly yellow fever, until respective governments removed the breeding grounds of mosquitoes. Today dengue fever has made a reappearance in Key West and the advice remains the same as in Dr Reed's day: get rid of stagnant fresh water to eliminate mosquito habitat, and because people aren't used to dealing with deadly disease the advice falls on deaf ears. I contracted dengue when I was on assignment in El Salvador twenty years ago. Salvadorans died, I got a horrible fever, and I discovered why they used to call it "breakbone fever," such was the pain. Dengue is also transmitted by mosquitoes and El Salvador wracked by civil war was in no position to carry out public works programs.

Louis Pasteur in France followed up vaccination work with discoveries in the field of anthrax and rabies and saved a child's life with an experimental vaccine. In 19th century France, and elsewhere, stray dogs were a feared threat as one bite from a rabid animal promised a horrible, writhing, foaming death. Rabies was terrifying and Pasteur's inoculation made him the object of adoration.

These are just a few of the giants, the most well known giants in the field of public medicine in the past couple of centuries. Their work is how we as a species figured out how to eradicate ghastly diseases. I well remember young kids coughing their chests out with "whooping" cough, a hacking chest condition so severe it sounded like the victims were literally going to split their young bodies apart from coughing. I remember spending an eternity in a dark isolated room with measles, I remember eating a sugar lump to prevent polio. Nowadays it seems no one remembers any of it. Yesterday I went to get my free swine flu vaccine, thinking grateful thoughts about Jenner, Pasteur and Reed among others, grateful we still have some sort of public health department in the US, and at home my wife tells me most of her students aren't vaccinated because parents fear the vaccine. Most of my colleagues refused the free vaccine- and half of the twelve of us are sick, coughing and hacking. One has swine flu and is in isolation at home "sounding like death." Hyperbole I know but swine flu is horrid and why would anyone refuse a vaccine? Because it's a government plot they say, because vaccine causes autism, because people are uneducated, ungrateful and deserve what they get. God, if you exist, please give me strength.

11 comments:

Singing to Jeffrey's Tune said...

Amen

Jack Riepe said...

Dear Conch:

As the father of a beautiful daughter, I will never forget the tense 72-hour waiting period that followed the last of her innoculations as an infant. A prominent television news magazine -- it may have been 60 Minutes -- had just exposed the fact that an increase of infant death syndrome had been linked to the 6-in-1 shot, which appeared to trigger a fatal allergic reaction in a small percentage of babies.

When I questioned her perdiatrician,he acknowledged the relationship between the vaccine and infant death. In fact, he had administered this serum to the baby of his best friend. The child was dead in 24-hours.

According to the broadcast, two drug companies developed a 6-in-1 type shot. One was a "clean" vaccine. The other was a "dirty" serum that on occasion triggered ther allergic reaction.

Naturally, the "clean" vaccine was difficult to make and sustain, hence it was more expensive. But the big surprise was when the company that made the dirty, cheaper vaccine purchased the rights to the "clean" one and ended the preoject.

The moral of the story is that some pharmaceutical company decided that the death of one baby in 300,000 (not sure of the real stat) was an acceptible loss. All I could think of when I held my sleeping Katherine in my arms that night was, "I hope I haven't killed you, trying to keep you well."

Banks... Insurance companies... Pharmaceutical companies... All have something in common with hot dog stands. They are in business to sell hot dogs. And if they have to starve, cheat, or poison a few innocent bystanders to benefit the majority (of stockholders), who gives a shit?

Not our elected officials, including the current crop of whores -- and I do mean "Stuttering Bob" in the White House -- who routinely take money from these ghouls as they craft legislation.

Here are the three biggest lies in the world:
1) I've never done this before.
2) I won't come in your mouth.
3) It's in the industry's best interest to police themselves, according to guidelines the industry has helped the federal government draft.

Number #2 and #3 are actually pretty close to the same thing.

Have a great day.

Fondest regards,
Jack • reep • Toad

Singing to Jeffrey's Tune said...

There is credence in the saying "people that espoused statistics have never been one".

However, I would rather not have the alternative.

Nor do I condone the antics of the "Ford Pinto" DOT case, nor the lesser known DOW Chemical Scotch Guard case (another statistical snafu played for money).

So - where does your conscious and common sense allow you to draw the line?

Conchscooter said...

Government regulations work. Privatization of the military, of utlities of health care of prisons doesn't. add to the list at will. Vaccines do work.

Jack Riepe said...

Dear Conch:

"Vaccinations do work..." Usually. As in the case of the story I told, the same vaccine worked much better in Britain, where the child is older when innoculated.

1) Read everything carefully
2) Ask questions
3) Demand answers
4) Demand action
5) When #two or #3 are not forthcoming, take action.

There is a huge difference in something that is "good" for you, and something that someone else has determined is "good enough."

Ever hear of thalidamyde, DDT, and VIOXX? All government approved.

I didn't get my H1N1 shot yet. A) Younger people are in more desperate need of this than I am (like my kid). B) There's none immediately available here. A politician friend of mine can get me a shot in the next state, but I felt funny about that.

I can difficult, huh?

Fondest regards,
Jack • reep • Toad
Twisted Roads

Anonymous said...

Glad we got ours. We will still be standing.

Conchscooter said...

I don't believe in forced vaccinations in a free society. I think choosing not to get vaccinated is the modern equivalent of relying on prayer and meditation to keep the black death away.Europe's population was decimated by God in the Middle Ages despite their earnest prayers. I'd rather rely on a needle thanks.Life is a matter of playing the odds, nothing is certain, if it were it wouldn't be life. The problem is when someone hears there is a one in a million chance they freak out. Look around and figure ytour odds of getting swine flu and do the math.
You are a problem child I plan to see if I can drink you under the table in spring and make you see sense after I complete my 1500 mile bun burner to Long Island.

Andrew A said...

A powerful post. Thanks.

Conchscooter said...

When Goldman Sachs executives get the vaccine ahead of New York hospitals you just know the risk of contracting autism is unacceptably high and they are sacrificing themselves as guinea pigs. Good people.

kathy said...

Here's a link to an article that offers the other side of the coin to the vaccine debate.

http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2009/11/14/Expert-Pediatrician-Exposes-Vaccine-Myths.aspx

It helps to see many aspects of an issue to make informed decisions. And I personally believe that vaccine decisions should be personal, not mandated.

Conchscooter said...

There is no doubt that cleanliness, diet and nutrition and sleep and all that help people. But you can be as healthy as a horse and small pox and yellow fever remain highly dangerous diseases.
No human activity is one percent safe yet if you ask the agitated riepe is his daughter got any of the six diseases she was immunised against he will be happy i am SURE to tell you no.
Then he will go on about the dangers of vaccination.
Like I said earlier vaccinations should be voluntary, but I believe our eco problems today come from over population so a little superstition, a lot of fear and a few nasty diseases may very well sort that out too. Too bad for the kids crippled by polio but that would be what the military call "collateral damage."